I read this article over at the New York Daily News:
Move over, Beatles. Mariah Carey is on the verge of tying the legendary British band for having the most chart-topping hits.
The hip-hop diva’s newest single “Touch My Body” is poised to give her 18 No. 1 singles, knotting her with the Fab Four.
Man, that comes with so many caveats it’s hard to address them all. So, I’ll just tackle a few of them real quick. First of all, here’s a timeline of The Beatles’ #1’s:
Now, due to one caveat, it can be argued that The Beatles had twenty, not eighteen #1’s. This is because two “singles” were actually doubles. Eleanor Rigby and We Can Work it Out were both B sides that acheived #1 status as well. People don’t do that much any more. For that matter, I don’t think you can even buy 45’s any more. Each song now is marketed totally independently. So, the market is different today than it was forty years ago. Given that, I think most people would go with the twenty #1’s as opposed to eighteen.
Secondly, it took The Beatles six years to get those twenty ( or eighteen ) #1’s. Here’s Mariah’s list ( so far ):
If #18 makes it this year, it will have taken her eighteen years to do what The Beatles did in six. Not exactly the same airplay dominance.
But wait, that’s not all to me. Another small caveat is The Beatles were actually four ( or more ) different individuals, which Mariah Carey is as well. If you look at the results of the individuals, the picture changes dramatically. Paul McCartney has had nine #1’s as a post-Beatle
, giving him 29 #1’s to Carey’s 17. George Harrison had three #1’s
before his death
, leaving him at 23. John Lennon
had two before his death, leaving him at 22. Ringo Starr had two as well, leaving him at 22. Looking at it this way, the list changes a lot:
- McCartney, 29
- Harrison, 23
- Lennon, 22
- Starr, 22
- Carey, 17
Or, you can look at it this way:
- The Beatles, 36
- Carey, 17
To be in the same boat as the individuals of The Beatles, she’s got a long way to go.
Finally, the impact of The Beatles at the time wasn’t so much their hit songs, it was their impact on society. From war protests to fashion to changing the entire recording industry, The Beatles, or a Beatle, was in the forefront. A lot can be argued whether it was good or bad, but it was incredibly profound for a bunch of punk musicians from Liverpool. I really don’t think Mariah’s done much of anything other than sell records. So, comparing record sells by divas to the impact of The Beatles just isn’t going to fly for anyone that has a clue.
Sphere: Related Content
Technorati Tags: beatles, george harrison, john lennon, mariah carey, paul mccartney, ringo starr